| Most Points, Team: 4383 |
| Milan |
| Most Points, Player: 1769 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most Points per Game, Team: 52.2 |
| Milan |
| Most Points per Game, Player: 32.2 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most Points in a Game, Team: 86 |
| Polo on 1/11/2021 vs. Northland Christian |
| Most Points in a Game, Player: 53 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan on 1/18/2022 vs. South Harrison |
| Most Field Goals, Team: 1665 |
| Polo |
| Most Field Goals, Player: 627 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most Field Goals per Game, Team: 20.1 |
| Polo |
| Most Field Goals per Game, Player: 11.4 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most Field Goals in a Game, Team: 36 |
| Polo on 1/11/2021 vs. Northland Christian |
| Most Field Goals in a Game, Player: 19 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan on 1/18/2022 vs. South Harrison |
| Hanna Vaught, Polo on 11/27/2023 vs. North Harrison |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals, Team: 455 |
| Milan |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals, Player: 211 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals per Game, Team: 5.4 |
| Milan |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals per Game, Player: 3.8 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals in a Game, Team: 11 |
| Milan on 1/20/2021 vs. Hamilton |
| Most 3-Point Field Goals in a Game, Player: 8 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan on 12/30/2020 vs. Maysville |
| Cady Pauley, Milan on 1/20/2021 vs. Hamilton |
| Marian Dabney, Milan on 11/21/2023 vs. Novinger |
| Most Free Throws Made, Team: 799 |
| Princeton |
| Most Free Throws Made, Player: 304 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most Free Throws Made per Game, Team: 10.0 |
| Princeton |
| Most Free Throws Made per Game, Player: 5.5 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan |
| Most Free Throws Made in a Game, Team: 27 |
| South Harrison on 2/17/2023 vs. Plattsburg |
| Most Free Throws Made in a Game, Player: 20 |
| Cady Pauley, Milan on 2/22/2022 vs. South Harrison |